Please wait a minute...


遥感技术与应用  2018, Vol. 33 Issue (6): 983-993    DOI: 10.11873/j.issn.1004-0323.2018.6.0983
(中国科学院南京地理与湖泊研究所湖泊与环境国家重点实验室,江苏 南京  210008)
Strategy and Method for Satellite Precipitation Data Evaluation:An Overview
Guo Ruifang,Liu Yuanbo
(State Key Laboratory of Lake Science and Environment,Nanjing Institute of Geographyand Limnology,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Nanjing 210008,China)
 全文: PDF(1142 KB)  


关键词: 精度遥感降水数据检验策略检验方法尺度    

Satellites offer a way of estimating global precipitation.Errors exist inevitably in satellite precipitation products,and have a great deal of difference among products because of the complexity of estimating or retrieving precipitation.This paper firstly outlined global projects of satellite precipitation product evaluationincluding Algorithm Intercomparison Project (AIP),Product Intercomparison Project (PIP),and Program to Evaluate High Resolution Precipitation Products (PEHRPP).These projects concluded that the accuracy of precipitation products is close related with underlying surfaces,latitude,seasons and precipitation patterns.The HRPPs (TMPA、CMORPH、NRLB and GSMaP) underestimate rainfall ranging from 3 to 7 mm/day(10%~67%).PERSIANN overestimates heavy rainfall (200%) while underestimates rainfall (56%) in the mountains.Then it concluded evaluation strategies including rainfall events evaluation,evaluation at meso-small scale region and evaluation at large scale region.Evaluation methods were divided into two categories,evaluation based on ground measurement data and evaluation based on satellite precipitation products.We introduced general evaluation procedure,including obtaining reference data,study area selection and data comparison.The reference datasets mainly include gauge data,Global Precipitation Climatology Centre (GPCC) datasets and radar data.Finally,we made a prospect on satellite precipitation product evaluation based on the existing problems at present.There currently exist three problems in satellite precipitation products evaluation,imperfect evaluation strategy,non-uniform reference data and evaluation indices.The future research aspects may include optimization of evaluation strategy,normalization of reference data and evaluation methods.

Key words: Accuracy    Satellite precipitation data    Evaluation strategy    Evaluation method    Scale
出版日期: 2019-01-29
ZTFLH:  P412.27  
基金资助: 国家自然科学基金重点项目“通江湖泊干旱的多成因机制研究”(41430855),国家高技术研究发展计划项目“星基地综合定量遥感系统与应用示范”(2013AA12A301)资助。
作者简介: 郭瑞芳(1986-),女,内蒙古乌兰察布人,博士,主要从事降水遥感研究。。
E-mail Alert


郭瑞芳, 刘元波. 遥感降水数据精度检验策略及检验方法综述[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(6): 983-993.

Guo Ruifang, Liu Yuanbo. Strategy and Method for Satellite Precipitation Data Evaluation:An Overview. Remote Sensing Technology and Application, 2018, 33(6): 983-993.


[1]Kidd C.Satellite Rainfall Climatology:A Review[J].International Journal of Climatology,2001,21(9):1041-1066.<br /> [2]Barrett E C,Beaumont M J.Satellite Rainfall Monitoring:An Overview[J].Remote Sensing Reviews,1994,11(1-4):23-48.<br /> [3]Kidd C,Levizzani V,Laviola S.Quantitative Precipitation Estimation from Earth Observation Satellites[J].Rainfall:State of the Science,Geophysical Monograph Series,2010,191(1):127-158.<br /> [4]Petty G W.The Status of Satellite-based Rainfall Estimation over Land[J].Remote Sensing of Environment,1995,51(1):125-137.<br /> [5]Nijssen B,Lettenmaier D P.Effect of Precipitation Sampling Error on Simulated Hydrological Fluxes and States:Anticipating the Global Precipitation Measurement Satellites[J].Journal of Geophysical Research,2004,109(D2):265-274.<br /> [6]Ebert E E,Manton M J,Arkin P A,et al.Results from the GPCP Algorithm Intercomparison Programme[J].Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society,1996,77(12):2875-2887.<br /> [7]Arkin P A,Xie P.The Global Precipitation Climatology Project:First Algorithm IntercomparisonProject[J].Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society,1994,75(3):401-419.<br /> [8]Ebert E E,Manton M J.Performance of Satellite Rainfall Estimation Algorithms during TOGA COARE[J].Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences,1998,55(9):1537-1557.<br /> [9]Barrett E C,Dodge J,Goodman H M,et al.TheFirst WetNet Precipitation Intercomparison Project (PIP-1)[J].Remote Sensing Reviews,1994,11(1-4):49-60.<br /> [10]Barrett E C,Adler R F,Arpe K,et al.The First WetNet Precipitation Intercomparison Project (PIP-1):Interpretation of Results[J].Remote Sensing Reviews,1994,11(1-4):303-373.<br /> [11]Kniveton D R,Motta B C,Goodman H M,et al.The First WetNet Precipitation Intercomparison Project:Generation of Results[J].Remote Sensing Reviews,1994,11(1-4):243-301.<br /> [12]Smith E A,Lamm J E,Adler R,et al.Results of WetNet PIP-2 Project[J].Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences,1998,55(9):1483-1536.<br /> [13]Adler R F,Kidd C,Petty G,et al.Intercomparison of Global Precipitation Products:The Third Precipitation Intercomparison Project (PIP-3)[J].Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society,2000,82(7):1377-1396.<br /> [14]Dodge J C,Goodman H M.TheWetNetproject[J].Remote Sensing Reviews,1994,11(1-4):5-21.<br /> [15]Arkin P,Turk J,Ebert B,et al.Evaluation of High Resolution Precipitation Forecasts and Analyses from Satellite Observations[C]∥AGU Fall Meeting Abstracts.2006,1:04.<br /> [16]Xie P,Arkin P A.An Intercomparison of Gauge Observations and Satellite Estimates of Monthly Precipitation[J].Journal of Applied Meteorology,1995,34(5):1143-1160.<br /> [17]Tian Y,Peters-Lidard C D,Choudhury B J,et al.Multitemporal Analysis of TRMM-based Satellite Precipitation Products for Land Data Assimilation Applications[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2007,8(6):1165-1183.<br /> [18]Tian Y,Peters-Lidard C D,Adler R F,et al.Evaluation of GSMaP Precipitation Estimates over the Contiguous United States[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2010,11(2):566-574.<br /> [19]Romilly T G,Gebremichael M.Evaluation of Satellite Rainfall Estimates over Ethiopian River Basins[J].Hydrology and Earth System Sciences,2011,15(5):1505-1514.<br /> [20]Prakash S,Sathiyamoorthy V,Mahesh C,et al.An Evaluation of High-resolution Multisatellite Rainfall Products over the Indian Monsoon Region[J].International Journal of Remote Sensing,2014,35(9):3018-3035.<br /> [21]Smith E A,Asrar G,Furuhama Y,et al.International Global PrecipitationMeasurement (GPM) Program and Mission:An Overview[A].Smith E A,Bauer P,Turk J,Measuring Precipitation from Space[M].Springer,Dordrecht,Netherlands,2007:611- 653.<br /> [22]Tustison B,Harris D,Foufoula-Georgiou E.Scale Issues in Verification of Precipitation Forecasts[J].Journal of Geophysical Research:Atmospheres (1984-2012),2001,106(D11):11775-11784.<br /> [23]Tustison B,Foufoula-Georgiou E,Harris D.Scale-recursive Estimation for Multisensor Quantitative Precipitation Forecast Verification:A Preliminary Assessment[J].Journal of Geophysical Research:Atmospheres (1984-2012),2002,107(D8):CIP 2-1-cIP 2-14.<br /> [24]Sorooshian S,Aghakouchak A,Arkin P,et al.Advanced Concepts on Remote Sensing of Precipitation at Multiple Scales[J].Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society,2011,92(10):1353-1357.<br /> [25]Levizzani V E.First Workshop of the International Precipitation Working Group[C]∥EUMETSAT,Publication P.43,2003:290.[Available from EUMETSAT,Am Kavalleriesand 31,D-64295 Darmstadt,Germany].<br /> [26][KG*4/5]Turk J,Bauer P.The International Precipitation Working Group andIts Role in the Improvement of Quantitative Precipitation Measurements[J].Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society,2006,87(5):643-647.<br /> [27][KG*4/5]Ebert E E,Janowiak J E,Kidd C.Comparison of Near-real-Time Precipitation Estimates from Satellite Observations and Numerical Models[J].Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society,2007,88(1):47-64.<br /> [28]Gottschalck J,Meng J,Rodell M,et al.Analysis of Multiple Precipitation Products and Preliminary Assessment of Their Impact on Global Land Data Assimilation System Land Surface States[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2005,6(5):573-598.<br /> [29]Xie P,Yatagai A,Chen M,et al.A Gauge-based Analysis of Daily Precipitation over East Asia[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2007,8(3):607-625.<br /> [30]Brown J E M.An Analysis of the Performance of Hybrid Infrared and Microwave Satellite Precipitation Algorithms over India and Adjacent Regions[J].Remote Sensing of Environment,2006,101(1):63-81.<br /> [31]Turk F J,Arkin P,Sapiano M R P,et al.Evaluating High-resolution Precipitation Products[J].Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society,2008,89(12):1911-1916.<br /> [32]Tobler W.On the First Law of Geography:AReply[J].Annals of the Association of American Geographers,2004,94(2):304-310.<br /> [33]Li Xiaowen,Cao Chunxiang,Chang Chaoyi.The First Law of Geography and Spatial-Temporal Proximity[J].Chinese Journal of Nature,2007,29(2):69-71.[李小文,曹春香,常超一.地理学第一定律与时空邻近度的提出[J].自然杂志,2007,29(2):69-71.]<br /> [34][JP2]Hong Y,Gochis D,Cheng J T,et al.Evaluation of PERSIANN-cCS Rainfall Measurement Using the NameEvent Rain Gauge Network[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2007,8(3):469-482.[JP]<br /> [35]Habib E,Henschke A,Adler R F.Evaluation of TMPA Satellite-based Research and Real-Time Rainfall Estimates during Six Tropical-related Heavy Rainfall Events over Louisiana,USA[J].Atmospheric Research,2009,94(3):373-388.<br /> [36]Prat O P,Barros A P.Assessing Satellite-based Precipitation Estimates in the Southern Appalachian Mountains Using Rain Gauges and TRMM PR[J].Advances in Geosciences,2010,25(25):143-153.<br /> [37]Aghakouchak A,Behrangi A,Sorooshian S,et al.Evaluation of Satellite-retrieved Extreme Precipitation Rates across the Central United States[J].Journal of Geophysical Research Atomspheres,2011,116:3-25.<br /> [38]Stampoulis D,Anagnostou E N,Nikolopoulos E I.Assessment of High-resolution Satellite-based Rainfall Estimates over the Mediterranean during Heavy Precipitation Events[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2013,14(5):1500-1514<br /> [39]Sohn B J,Han H J,Seo E K.Validation of Satellite-based High-resolution Rainfall Products over the Korean Peninsula Using Data from ADense Rain Gauge Network[J].Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology,2010,49(4):701-714.<br /> [40]Gebremichael M,Krajewski W F,Morrissey M L,et al.A Detailed Evaluation of GPCP 1° Daily Rainfall Estimates over the Mississippi River Basin[J].Journal of Applied Meteorology,2005,44:665-681.<br /> [41]Villarini G,Krajewski W F.Evaluation of the Research Version TMPA Three-hourly 0.25°×0.25° Rainfall Estimates over Oklahoma[J].Geophysical Research Letters,2007,34(5),L05402:1-5.<br /> [42][KG*4/5]Chokngamwong R,Chiu L S.Thailand Daily Rainfall and Comparison with TRMM Products[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2008,9(2):256-266.<br /> [43]Hirpa F A,Gebremichael M,Hopson T.Evaluation of High-resolution Satellite Precipitation Products over Very Complex Terrain in Ethiopia[J].Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology,2010,49(5):1044-1051.<br /> [44][JP]Tian Y,Peters-Lidard C D,Eylander J B,et al.Component Analysis of Errors in Satellite-based Precipitation Estimates[J].Journal of Geophysical Research:Atmospheres (1984-2012),2009,114(D24):1-15.doi:10.1029/2009JD011949,2009.[JP]<br /> [45]Tian Y,Peters-Lidard C D.A Global Map of Uncertainties in Satellite-based Precipitation Measurements[J].Geophysical Research Letters,2010,37(24):1-6.doi:10.1029/2010GL 046008,2010.<br /> [46]Demaria E M C,Rodriguez D A,Ebert E E,et al.Evaluation of Mesoscale Convective Systems in South America Using Multiple Satellite Products and An Object-based Approach[J].Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres,2011,116(D8):353-366.<br /> [47]Gao Y C,Liu M F.Evaluation of High-resolution Satellite Precipitation Products Using Rain Gauge Observations over the Tibetan Plateau[J].Hydrology and Earth System Sciences,2013,17(2):837-849.<br /> [48]Salio P,Hobouchian M P,Skabar Y G,et al.Evaluation of High-resolution Satellite Precipitation Estimates over Southern South America Using ADense Rain Gauge Network[J].Atmospheric Research,2014,163:146-161.<br /> [49]Qu Wei,Lu Jingxuan,Song Wenlong,et al.Research on Accurate Validation and Calibration Methods of TRMM Remote Sensing Precipitation Data in Irrawaddy Basin[J].Advance in Earth Acience,2014,29(11):1262-1270.[ 曲伟,路京选,宋文龙,等.TRMM遥感降水数据在伊洛瓦底江流域的精度检验和校正方法研究[J].地球科学进展,2014,29(11):1262-1270.]<br /> [50]Dinku T,Ceccato P,Grover-Kopec E,et al.Validation of Satellite Rainfall Products over East Africa's Complex Topography[J].International Journal of Remote Sensing,2007,28(7):1503-1526.<br /> [51]Thiemig V,Rojas R,Zambranobigiarini M,et al.Validation of Satellite-based Precipitation Products over Sparsely Gauged African River Basins[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2012,13(6):1760-1783.<br /> [52]ChengKe,Zhu Zhen,Li Ming,et al.Application and Accuracy Testing of TRMM3B43 Rainfall Product in Tibetan Region[J].Journal of Materials Sciences and Technology,2014,45(1):44-46.[程珂,朱祯,李铭,等.TRMM3B43降水产品在西藏地区的精度检验和应用[J].水利水电技术,2014,45(1):44-46.]<br /> [53]Zeng Hongwei,Li Lijuan.Accuracy Validation of TRMM 3B43 Data in Lancang River Basin[J].Acta Geographica Sinica,2011,66(7):994-1004.[曾红伟,李丽娟.澜沧江及周边流域TRMM3B43数据精度检验[J].地理学报,2011,66(7):994-1004.]<br /> [54]Justice C,Belward A,Morisette J,et al.Developments in the 'Validation' of Satellite Sensor Products for the Study of the Land Surface[J].International Journal of Remote Sensing,2000,21(17):3383-3390.<br /> [55]Rodgers C D.Inverse Methods for Atmospheric Sounding[M].Theory and Practice.Series on Atmospheric,Oceanic and Planetary Physics,Volume 2.World Scientific Publishing Co.,Inc.,River Edge,New Jersey,USA,2000.[JP]<br /> [56]JCGM,International Vocabulary of Metrology-Basic and General Concepts and Associated Terms[R].Technology Report,BIPM,2012.<br /> [57]Loew A,Bell W,Brocca L,et al.Validation Practices for Satellite based Earth Observation Data across Communities[J].Reviews of Geophysics,2017(6):779-817.<br /> [58]Krajewski W F,Smith J A.Radar Hydrology:Rainfall Estimation[J].Advances in Water Resources,2002,25:1387-1394.<br /> [59]Ciach G J,Krajewski W F.On the Estimation of Radar Rainfall Error Variance[J].Advances in Water Resources,1999,22(6):585-595.<br /> [60]Gebremichael M.Framework for Satellite Rainfall Product Evaluation[J].Geophysical Monograph,2010,191(1):265-275.<br /> [61]Nair S,Srinivasan G,Nemani R.Evaluation of Multi-satellite TRMM Derived Rainfall Estimates over a Western State of India[J].Journal of the Meteorological Society of Japan,2009,87(6):927-939.<br /> [62]As-syakur A R,Tanaka T,PrasetiaR,et al.Comparison of TRMM Multisatellite Precipitation Analysis (TMPA) Products and Daily-Monthly Gauge Data over Bali[J].International Journal of Remote Sensing,2011,32(24):8969-8982.<br /> [63]Karaseva M O,Prakash S,Gairola R M.Validation of High-resolution TRMM-3B43 Precipitation Product Using Rain Gauge Measurements over Kyrgyzstan[J].Theoretical and Applied Climatology,2012,108:147-157.<br /> [64]Ouma Y,Owiti T,Kibiiy J,et al.Multitemporal Comparative Analysis of TRMM-3B42 Satellite-Estimated Rainfall with Surface Gauge Data at Basin Scales:Daily,Decadal and Monthly Evaluations[J].International Journal of Remote Sensing,2012,33(24):7662-7684.<br /> [65]Prakash S,Gairola R M.Validation of TRMM-3B42 Precipitation Product over the Tropical Indian Ocean Using Rain Gauge Data from the RAMA Buoy Array[J].Theoretical and Applied Climatology,2014,115(3-4):451-460.<br /> [66]Bowman K P.Comparison of TRMM Precipitation Retrievals with Rain Gauge Data from Ocean Buoys[J].Journal of Climate,2010,18(1):178-190.<br /> [67]Bell T L,Kundu P K.Comparing Satellite Rainfall Estimates with Rain Gauge Data:Optimal Strategies Suggested by ASpectral Model[J].Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres,2002,108(D3):145-160.<br /> [68]Zeweldi D A,Gebremichael M.Evaluation of CMORPH Precipitation Products at Fine Space-Time Scales[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2009,10(1):300-307.[BF]<br /> [69]Krajewski W F.Ground Networks:Are We Doing the Right Thing?[M].Measuring Precipitation from Space.Springer,Dordrecht,Netherlands,2007:403-417.<br /> [70][KG*5/6]Villarini G,Mandapaka P V,Krajewski W F,et al.Rainfall and Sampling Uncertainties:A Rain Gauge Perspective[J].Journal of Geophysical Rsearch,2008,113(1):D11102:1-12.<br /> [71][KG*4/5]Ciach.Local Random Errors in Tipping-Bucket Rain Gauge Measurements[J].Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic,2003,20(20):752-759.<br /> [72][KG*4/5]Guo Ruifang,Liu Yuanbo.Multi-satellite Retrieval of High Resolution Precipitation:An Overview[J].Advances in Earth Science,2015,30(8):891-903.[郭瑞芳,刘元波.多传感器联合反演高分辨率降水方法综述[J].地球科学进展,2015,30(8):891-903.]<br /> [73]Sapiano M R P,Arkin P A.An Intercomparison and Validation of High-resolution Satellite Precipitation Estimates with 3-Hourly Gauge Data[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2009,10(1):149-166.<br /> [74]Yu Z,Yu H,Chen P,et al.Verification of Tropical Cyclone-related Satellite Precipitation Estimates in Mainland China[J].Journal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology,2009,48(11):2227-2241.<br /> [75]Dinku T,Ruiz F,Connor S J,et al.Validation and Intercomparison of Satellite Rainfall Estimates over Colombia[J].Journal of Applied Meteorology & Climatology,2010,49(5):1004-1014.<br /> [76]Qin Y,Chen Z,Shen Y,et al.Evaluation of Satellite Rainfall Estimates over the Chinese Mainland[J].Remote Sensing,2014,6(11):11649-11672.<br /> [77]Li Z,Yang D,Hong Y.Multi-scale Evaluation of High-resolution Multi-sensor Blended Global Precipitation Products over the Yangtze River[J].Journal of Hydrology,2013,500(14):157-169.<br /> [78]Su F,Hong Y,Lettenmaier D P.Evaluation of TRMM Multisatellite Precipitation Analysis (TMPA) and Its Utility in Hydrologic Prediction in the La Plata Basin[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2008,9(4):622-640.<br /> [79]Kidd C,Bauer P,Turk J,et al.Intercomparison of High-resolution Precipitation Products over Northwest Europe[J].Journal of Hydrometeorology,2012,13(7):1377-1396.<br /> [80]Rudolf B,Becker A,Schneider U,et al.NewFull Data Reanalysis Version 5 Provides High-Quality Gridded Monthly Precipitation Data[J].GEWEX News,2011,21(2):4-5.<br /> [81]Becker A,Finger P,Meyer-christofferA,et al.A Description of the Global Land-surface Precipitation Data Products of the Global Precipitation Climatology Centre with Sample Applications Including Centennial(Trend) Analysis from 1901-Present[J].Earth System Science Data,2013,5:921-998.<br /> [82]Schneider U,Becker A,Finger P,et al.GPCC’s New Land Surface Precipitation Climatology based on Quality-controlled in Situ Dataand Its Role in Quantifying the Global Water Cycle[J].Theoretical and Applied Climatology,2014,115:15-40. <p>   </p>
[1] 王轩, 郝晓华, 王建, 车涛, 李弘毅, 邵东航. 中国地区AVHRR长时间序列积雪范围产品精度评估[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(6): 994-1003.
[2] 汪子豪, 秦其明, 孙元亨.

基于BP神经网络的地表温度空间降尺度方法 [J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(5): 793-802.

[3] 苗翔鹰, 苗洪利, 张旭东, 黄霞凤, 王桂忠. 利用星下点干涉相位法提高三维成像高度计测高精度[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(5): 866-872.
[4] 韩涛, 潘剑君, 张培育, 曹罗丹. Sentinel-2A与Landsat-8影像在油菜识别中的差异性研究[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(5): 890-899.
[5] 刘畅,李震,张平,田帮森,周建民. 基于Google Earth Engine评估新疆西南部MODIS积雪产品[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(4): 584-592.
[6] 施佩荣,陈永富,刘华,吴云华. 基于分割评价函数的多尺度分割参数的选择[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(4): 628-637.
[7] 任浙豪,周坚华. 增大特征空间复杂度的方法——以城镇下垫面遥感分类为[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(3): 408-417.
[8] 丁哲,汪小钦,邬群勇. 遥感影像空间分辨率对城市建筑物高度估算精度的影响[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(3): 418-427.
[9] 王宁,陈方,于博. 基于形态学开运算的面向对象滑坡提取方法研究[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(3): 520-529.
[10] 李珊珊,蒋耿明. 基于通用分裂窗算法和Landsat-8数据的地表温度反演研究[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(2): 284-295.
[11] 江东,陈帅,丁方宇,付晶莹,郝蒙蒙. 基于面向对象的遥感影像分类研究——以河北省柏乡县为例[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(1): 143-150.
[12] 何艺,周小成,黄洪宇,许雪琴. 基于无人机遥感的亚热带森林林分株数提取[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2018, 33(1): 168-176.
[13] 曹晓晨,尤红建,刘佳音,王峰. 基于误差建模的SRTM高程精度提升方法研究[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2017, 32(5): 801-808.
[14] 李艳,侯金亮,黄春林. 基于Copula函数的地表温度空间降尺度研究[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2017, 32(5): 818-824.
[15] 唐超,邵龙义. 高光谱遥感地物目标识别算法及其在岩性特征提取中的应用[J]. 遥感技术与应用, 2017, 32(4): 691-697.